نوع مقاله : مقاله استخراج شده از پایان نامه
عنوان مقاله English
نویسندگان English
Introduction: Traditional public policymaking, based on full rationality, has failed to address behavioral dimensions of social and environmental challenges. Behavioral public policy emerged as a transformative paradigm, evolving from nudge and libertarian paternalism into behavioral governance. Despite exponential growth, the literature remains fragmented, lacking a comprehensive map of its intellectual structure and evolution. Previous bibliometric studies focused on specific applications or the behavioral state as an endpoint, not on the full conceptual evolution from nudge to behavioral governance through collaboration networks, thematic clusters, and temporal trends. This study fills this gap by providing a systematic, evidence-based analysis of the field's conceptual trajectory.
Methods: A bibliometric approach was used. A systematic search of Scopus and Web of Science (September 2, 2026) applied a unified strategy to titles, abstracts, and keywords, limited to English articles and reviews (2008–2026) in social sciences, economics, business, management, psychology, and decision sciences. The initial search retrieved 7,435 documents (Scopus: 4,617; Web of Science: 2,818). After removing 1,295 duplicates and screening, 1,419 documents remained. Analyses used VOSviewer (1.6.21), RStudio (2023.3.1.446), and Biblioshiny (bibliometrix in R, 4.5.1). Three levels were covered: citation-based performance analysis; citation network analysis (co-citation threshold: 20 citations; country co-authorship: 9 documents; keyword co-occurrence: 10 occurrences); and content analysis. Three periods were defined: 2008-2014, 2015-2019, and 2020-2026. Merging the two databases followed standard rules based on DOI and title-author-year matching. To ensure a coherent theoretical synthesis, the findings were systematically organized and interpreted through the TCCM framework (Theory, Context, Characteristics, Methodology). To this end, the research questions were designed to directly address the four dimensions of the TCCM framework, ensuring a structured and theory-driven synthesis of the findings.
Findings: Findings reveal a three-phase pattern: slow growth (2008–2014), gradual expansion (2015–2019), and exponential growth (2020–2026), indicating a shift in thematic patterns and concept expansion. Performance analysis showed Western dominance and concentration in specialized behavioral public policy and public administration journals. The co-authorship network was fragmented. Co-citation analysis identified 4 intellectual clusters (46 references): foundational behavioral economics and prospect theory; public policy and governance; ethics of behavioral interventions; and applied domains (health, environment, taxation). Keyword co-occurrence revealed 6 thematic clusters (57 keywords) and 5 conceptual dimensions: foundational behavioral concepts, public policy and governance, sectoral applications, psychological foundations, and emerging themes (behavioral governance, choice infrastructure). Thematic evolution showed a transition from nudge as a micro-level tool to behavioral governance as the evolved stage of behavioral public policy rather than an independent paradigm. Mapping these findings onto the TCCM framework indicates a methodological shift from micro-level experiments to systemic analyses (M), a theoretical transition from cognitive foundations to normative critiques (T), a contextual bias toward Western institutional settings (C), and a conceptual evolution from individual behavioral characteristics to systemic governance infrastructure (C).
Conclusions: This study maps the intellectual structure and evolution of behavioral public policy (2008–2026). The field has moved from individual-level nudges to a broader stage of behavioral governance, characterized by systemic, multi-level, and ethical approaches. Theoretically, it provides empirical evidence for this transition and maps the field's intellectual, social, and conceptual structures. Practically, it offers policymakers a roadmap for evidence-based, context-sensitive interventions, particularly in developing countries seeking to institutionalize behavioral insights. The main limitation is reliance on two databases and English-language documents. The study also highlights geographical bias and the need for more non-Western research, including Iran.
کلیدواژهها English